Asked on October 2, 2026

A crime is committed. What does society owe?

Punishment that matches the harm

61%

Rehabilitation above all else

39%

Vote on today's question

Comments

6 comments from that day

AU

AugustusRay_tech

Prisons don't rehabilitate. They warehouse people and break them further. We're doing it backwards.

0

RO

RosieMarkham_local

The question isn't what we owe—it's what actually works. Recidivism data shows punishment alone fails spectacularly.

0

PE

PennyWest88

Both? Why does it have to be one or the other? Proportional consequences AND genuine paths to change.

0

VI

VictorDaSilva_local

Rehabilitation sounds nice in theory but watch someone actually reoffend and tell me it was the right call.

0

LO

LorenzoMack

Society owes victims closure first. Everything else is secondary.

0

KA

KaylaRitchie_indie

Justice without accountability is just revenge dressed up. Punishment has to mean something or we're no better than the criminal.

0

More questions